Yoga’s Naked Commercialism – article by Stewart J Lawrence, guardian.co.uk |

4

March 21 by The Running Son

Yoga’s naked commercialism

The nude trend is stirring debate about how far yoga, now a multibillion-dollar industry, has travelled from its spiritual roots

Stewart J Lawrence byline

guardian.co.uk

Monday 18 October 2010 13.00 EDT

Kathryn Budig yoga guru

Yoga guru Kathryn Budig in the controversial ToeSox ad.
Photograph: Jasper Johal
.

American yoga practitioners are abuzz with a new controversy rocking their once boutique but now rapidly commercialising industry: magazine advertising and public yoga classes featuring unabashed nudity. The controversy pits seasoned yoga teachers and other spiritual purists, who abhor the growing trend, against a new generation of aggressive yoga “entrepreneurs”, anxious to promote the ancient Hindu practice as America’s premier “wellness” lifestyle – even if it means exploiting, as critics maintain, the female “beauty myth” and embracing a “sex-sells” marketing strategy.

So far, the two sides have largely confined their debate to articles and blog postings in popular online yoga magazines, including the industry’s trade publication, Yoga Journal, where nude and semi-nude ads featuring a prominent Los Angeles yoga teacher, Kathryn Budig, first started appearing last summer. Budig posed provocatively in ads for the clothing manufacturer ToeSox, which prompted one of the magazine’s original co-founders, Judith Hanson Lasater, to protest publicly, first in a letter to the editor, and more recently, in interviews.

For yoga purists, it’s bad enough that yoga is no longer the quiet, esoteric practice of yore. Thanks to heavy marketing, and word-of-mouth advertising, it’s now a bustling business worth $6bn a year and featuring a gallery of self-promoting yoga “celebrities” like Budig, and an endless array of high-priced yoga accessories, including sticky mats, CD-roms, home videos and pricey yoga retreats and vacations in exotic Third World getaways.

Until now, many have tolerated, and even celebrated, yoga’s commercialisation as a way of promoting its popularity, even if it means “dumbing down” the practice or heavily tailoring it to the traditional fitness market to further expand its appeal. According to Yoga Journal, some 18 million Americans – about 1 in 10 adults – were practising some form of yoga in 2006, though the numbers seem to have fallen off in recent years, even as the revenues generated by the industry continue to grow.

But something seems to have cracked inside the souls of long-time yoga enthusiasts when Budig agreed to be photographed wearing only her ToeSox. In one of the photographs in the series of ads, she’s in a difficult Ashtanga yoga pose, known as “firefly”, and her expresson is serious, but the effect is oddly disconcerting. Is it “art”, as some of its ardent proponents, including Budig and ToeSox executives maintain, or is it merely the latest twist in a long history of sexual and commercial exploitation?

The debate over nude advertising and health & fitness is hardly a new one. Four decades ago, Sports Illustrated caused an enormous stir when its cover featured a topless woman jogging on the beach. Critics, including me – yes, at the tender age of 10, I wrote a letter to the editor that was published – suggested, naively perhaps, that topless women simply don’t belong on the cover of a serious sports magazine. Others saw it as a celebration of the human body, and of the joyful exuberance that one experiences through jogging and other forms of exercise.

Clearly, our mores have changed – or have they? In 1999, women’s soccer player Brandi Chastain caused an enormous controversy when she spontaneously stripped off her jersey after kicking the goal that ensured her team’s victory. And Chastain didn’t expose her body – just her sports bra.

Male soccer players often doff their shirts, but, of course, men exposing their chests in public is commonplace. Amazingly, people to this day debate whether Chastain crossed an imaginary line of female “propriety”.

But is yoga somehow different? Perhaps. For one thing, it’s not meant to be a sports activity, and the persons exposing themselves, while celebrities of sorts, claim to be spiritual models, and some, like Budig, have direct contact with us, their students. According to Lasater:

“[A]ll this sexualisation of yoga through props and advertising [affects] the environment of yoga classes in ways that do not honour the boundary between teacher and student. I want to help create a safe space for yoga to be taught. In the US, we pay people the most money who can distract us the best: actors, personalities and sports figures. Entertainment is all about distraction. The use of naked bodies to sell yoga products is about using distraction to sell introspection.”

Others are equally worried that selling yoga with fit, trim bodies – almost all of them young and white – imposes the same harsh psychological burden on women that traditional fashion and beauty advertising does. Even more, perhaps, because women with serious psychological or physical health issues – such as obesity, as well as anorexia and bulimia – are drawn to yoga to affirm themselves, regardless of their “looks” or how they might feel about their bodies.

Budig, however, disagrees, and so do many yogis, especially – surprisingly, perhaps – many women. They see her as a courageous role model for self-expression, who is simply saying, I love my body, and what I can do it with it, and you should, too. But it is also clear that Budig is using the controversy to promote her own yoga business, and to enhance her own celebrity. Equally, ToeSox appears to be exploiting her yoga connection – and body – to appeal to a key consumer niche for its product.

The appearance of Budig’s ads – and others similarly controversial, including one titled “Say No to Cameltoe”, parallels the sudden emergence and rapid proliferation of “Naked Yoga”, yoga classes conducted entirely in the nude. Its founder, Aaron Star, says many people, especially in cities like New York and Los Angeles, don’t have ways to express closeness and intimacy without having sex, and that his practice affords that. But Star’s also heavily promoting Naked Yoga videos that feature full nudity and bear a strong resemblance to soft-core pornography. He’s even provocatively entitled one of his new videos apparently designed for the yoga beginner, “Hot Nude Yoga Virgin”.

But if so, why stop at nudity? It’s conceivable that someone might try to create a business that exploits yoga’s Tantric roots even further, promote studios where students can engage in erotic exchanges with their teachers? Actually, that already happens, but so far, no one’s figured out how to make a buck off of it, without actually breaking the law on solicitation.

Does all this fuss over yoga and sex reflect the enduring strength of American puritanism and prudishness? Are critics merely jealous killjoys? Supporters of Budig and the new nudity trend in yoga certainly think so. But it’s also true that yoga is one of the few industries of its size that exists with virtually no regulation – either from public authorities, or from within. Last summer, about the same time the nude trend emerged, New York and Virginia tried to impose state guidelines on yoga “teacher training” programmes – the programmes that are used to teach advanced students to become teachers themselves. But heavy lobbying by yoga associations in both states beat back those efforts, claiming yoga was a “spiritual” enterprise, much like a church, and should be “exempt” from all government interference.

A spiritual enterprise with revenues of $6bn a year? That’s some pose.

.

END
.
The Running Father Blog

4 thoughts on “Yoga’s Naked Commercialism – article by Stewart J Lawrence, guardian.co.uk |

  1. Matthew says:

    I’m a proud prude. Frankly, I don’t see the point in being naked around anyone but your wife or husband. She/he should be enough to satisfy a person. Group nudity is just an invitation for sexual temptation.

  2. Nicola says:

    I have been practicing yoga for about 6 years, and I completely agree with the author of this blog, and with others who find yoga trends disturbing. The fact is, true spirituality has never attracted the masses, and anything with profit in it will become corrupted. Yoga has gone the way of art, and few understand what I mean by that. Anyone can call themselves an artist as long as they go through the motions and market themselves as artists. Similarly, any body with the capacity to bend and flex can call itself a yoga instructor or even guru, and provided the mind exploits its own body it can make a ton of money. Naturally charlatans are attracted to this prospect. But few find this disturbing, whereas for me it feels very upsetting.

    It is a spiritual exercise just to live and observe the masses in this world, understand I am also one of them (even though I don’t have the same opinions as most people), yet still remain happy…

    The sources of yoga, the essential texts still exist, and we can continue our paths alone. I follow Eckart Yoga on the Internet. Anyway, the spiritual journey is nearly always solitary, excepting a teacher and one or two of the like-minded. It has never been for the masses.

  3. The naked yoga print ads bother me on several levels. As a woman attracted to both men and women, I say the female form wins out over the male form in a general beauty competition. In my opinion, the curves and softness of women make us “the fairer sex.” But even given my preference for the female form, I think we’re doing it a horrible disservice by running print ads like these.

    1. It suggests that only women who look like Kathryn Budig are beautiful/worthy of being in such a campaign. Would they want to take photographs of me in the buff and put them on billboards or on the sides of buses? No, they certainly would not. And because of crap like that, I struggle every day to believe my husband when he tells me I’m beautiful. What a shame it is to feel this way. If it’s really just about the beauty of the female form, then have the exact same campaign, but use someone who looks more like Rosie O’Donnell and maybe I’ll buy that line of bs. (FYI, I use Dove products precisely because they use “real women” in their advertisements.)

    2. This kind of marketing (as well as much of Yoga Journal’s articles) is targeted at middle/upper-middle class stay at home moms or the ladies who lunch crowd. These women are the epitome of the surbanite lifestyle. If they have children, they usually have nannies or multiple day activities for their children so they don’t actually have to participate in the learning development of their own children. If they have awesome bodies, it’s usually because they have personal chefs, nutritionists, and personal trainers. While I don’t devalue a waspy/yuppy from getting in touch with her inner peace through yoga, I think this kind of marketing tells people that if you’re not in this group, yoga’s just not for you. What of the poor, mentally ill, injured, or of the children or the elderly? Yoga is a beneficial exercise and mental conditioning tool for any person, but you wouldn’t know that by looking at these advertisements or at much of whats in Yoga Journal (of which I am a faithful subscriber). Community activists who also happen to be yogis are trying to change things and make things more diverse, but it’s an uphill battle for sure, and they’re just getting started. Kudos to groups like Curvy Yoga and Decolonizing Yoga for challenging the demographic staleness of stereotypical yogis.

    3. Using sex or sexuality to sell anything is reprehensible. Regardless of whether or not the subject is male or female, making money off of the sexuality of a human being devalues the beautiful and even sacred act of sex. Moreover it devalues humanity itself by turning us into sex objects. For the audience, it teaches us that sex and people are commodities, and that if you buy such-and-such product, you’ll be sexy (which really is to say that you’ll be worthy enough for another person to engage in sexual activity with you). It also teaches us as viewers that “this” is what’s sexy. Having some marketing department define what is or is not sexy for a culture is a gross overstepping of boundaries and it creates ONLY marginalization for anyone not meeting that definition. For the subjects in the advertisements, it tells them that the only contribution they’re able to make in this world is a visual, sexual one. What of their own personhood? Is Kathryn Budig more than just a beautiful, fit woman? I’m sure she is, but you wouldn’t know that by this advertisement. What contributions is she making to the world? By this print ad, she’s creating controversy and (I think) damaging the self image of anyone who sees it. How should she feel about that as a yoga teacher, as a woman?

    This is a soapbox issue for me, clearly. I hope I haven’t hijacked or monopolized your post with my response. Thank you for sharing this topic.

    • Your opinions are always welcome here. I don’t intend to force controversy, so commenting will remain slow unless a faithful few share their thoughts and start the ball rolling. From my perspective, every comment is valuable. I don’t want a ghost town.

♫ Talk to Jim...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

RFB editor Jim Aldrich, Joshua Tree CA 2013

RunningSon aka Jim Aldrich, Joshua Tree CA 2013 | This site is dedicated with the deepest gratitude to Dr. Cláudio Naranjo, whose writings gave me life.

  • 93,625 souls hit the RFB

Click to Follow the RFB!

Join 991 other followers

Some RFB Followers…

Flag Counter
via GiantGag.com

Killing time just got a lot funnier !

UP!::urban po'E.Tree(s)

by po'E.T. and the colors of pi

The shadows of a dream

Words walking the tightrope from functionality to versification.

Petals Unfolding

The Embrace of Love ~

Walkingtomydreams13

Everything I can live up to is Today.

galaktikapoetikeatunis

A topnotch WordPress.com site

forgottenmeadows

thoughts from my mind to yours

K. A. Bryce

Poetry, musings and sightings from where the country changes

annamosca

Just another WordPress.com site

Bilder

Ein schöner Tag - wenn er zu Ende geht, ist nichts mehr, wie es war...

realtalented

Im here to expose true talent

phillymanjim's Blog

Poetry, Musings, Photographs

Never Quite Broken

What you did not build up, you cannot tear down.

Blog It or Lose It!

Keeping my brain from turning into oatmeal...

Eli Glasman

Blog of author Eli Glasman

The Year(s) of Living Non-Judgmentally

Here and now, with all of it.

JamesRadcliffe.com

James Radcliffe, Musician. Music, Blog, Pictures, Live, News...

Tania Marie's Blog

Creating Life as a Work of Art

Sean Bidd

Nomadic & transient tales, with the occasional short piece of chaos.

Papermashed

Nurturing the creative within.

Smuggling Bay

About expression

leather green gargoyle

what I hear, what I read, what I write

Gray Poet

Just a place to express my poems.

The Tophat Raven

Art and literary magazine.

HA's Place

where I see, read, believe, aspire, dream, and of course Write

sharkouni

The greatest WordPress.com site in all the land!

Mr.Sahrul Santri

SaSatorial_SahrulSantriTutorial

Notes on a Spanish Valley

Award-winning blog - Living in rural Andalucia

greenlightlady

As a still lake reflects creation, so may our hearts reflect the Creator's glory ~ Wendy Macdonald

idealisticrebel

Women's Issues, Peace, Creativity & Spirituality

intotheindigo

My muse's quiet amusement

The Bully Pulpit

(n): An office or position that provides its occupant with an outstanding opportunity to speak out on any issue.

Poemotherapi Shoppe

"Oh How Art Thou Love Of Poetry"

hammerwerk

light_and_shadow

I didn't have my glasses on....

A trip through life with fingers crossed and eternal optimism.

The Sanctuary of My Heart

Words From My Heart to Yours

∙ tenderheartmusings ∙

we were born naked onto the page of existence; with nothing but the pen of our soul to write ourselves into eternal ecstasy ~ DreamingBear Baraka Kanaan

Traces of the Soul

Whispering Insights of this and that, then and here.

"we'll never be royals."

Small artists with big potential and lots of cliché.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 991 other followers

%d bloggers like this: